Loose Monetary Policy and Financial Instability

This paper provides the first long-run causal evidence that a persistently loose stance of monetary policy — defined as extended periods of low interest rates relative to the neutral rate — significantly raises the probability of a financial crisis several years later. Using a long historical panel of 18 advanced economies (approximately 1870–2020, excluding world wars), the paper estimates local projection (LP) regressions in which the stance is measured as the 5-year backward moving average of (r – r*), with r* from the Del Negro–Giannoni–Gaballo–Tambalotti (DGGT) factor model. The OLS baseline finds that a 1 percentage-point (pp) looser average stance over a 5-year window raises the 3-year financial crisis probability by 2.2pp at a 5–7 year horizon and 3.3pp at a 7–9 year horizon, against an unconditional base of 10.5%. To address the endogeneity of monetary policy to pre-existing economic conditions, the authors construct an instrumental variable based on the international trilemma of open-economy finance: for countries pegging their exchange rate, changes in the base-country interest rate orthogonal to domestic economic conditions provide exogenous variation in domestic rates, weighted by a capital mobility index. IV estimates are substantially larger: 1pp looser average stance raises crisis probability by 5.5pp at 5–7 years and 15.5pp at 7–9 years, indicating that OLS understates the causal effect because accommodative policy is endogenously adopted during recessions when crisis risk is already low. The same loose-policy stance significantly raises the probability of entering R-zones — periods of credit market overheating identified by Greenwood, Hanson, Shleifer, and Sørensen (2022) as harbingers of financial crisis — and, with a lag of 6–9 years, raises the probability of historically low GDP growth (below the 20th percentile of the cross-country distribution). The evidence supports a growth-risk tradeoff: loose policy may deliver short-term stimulus, but at a meaningful cost in medium-term financial fragility and real tail risk.

Maximilian Grimm | Macro Paper Warehouse

Loose Monetary Policy and Financial Instability