Bank Information Production Over the Business Cycle

Research Question

Banks produce private information about borrowers that is inherently unobservable to outside researchers. Howes and Weitzner ask whether the quality of this private information is countercyclical — that is, whether banks invest more in learning about borrowers when local economic conditions deteriorate — and whether any such cyclicality reflects endogenous information production incentives rather than exogenous changes in the information environment.

Data and Methodology

The paper uses the Federal Reserve’s Y-14Q Schedule H.1 confidential regulatory data, which covers commercial and industrial (C&I) loans exceeding $1 million originated by bank holding companies with $50 billion or more in total assets. This universe covers 85.9% of all banking sector assets and approximately 70% of all C&I loan volume (as documented by Bidder, Krainer, and Shapiro (2020)). A distinctive feature is that qualifying banks must report their internal probability of default (PD) estimates for each loan to the Federal Reserve. The sample is restricted to newly originated loans from 2014Q4 through 2019Q1 — the window over which PD data are well populated — with at least one year of subsequent observation to allow defaults to materialize. The outcome variable is a binary default indicator equal to one if the borrower defaults within two years of origination (0.41% of firms in the sample).

Cooper Howes | Macro Paper Warehouse

Bank Information Production Over the Business Cycle