Racial Disparities in Housing Returns

Research Question

This paper estimates the racial/ethnic gap in realized housing returns using administrative data on individual housing transactions, and investigates the mechanisms that generate those gaps. The central question is: why do Black and Hispanic homeowners accumulate less housing wealth than White homeowners, even as minority homeownership rates have risen substantially over the last century?

Data and Methodology

The authors merge three primary data sources. First, a nationwide panel of residential property records from ATTOM covering 146.8 million arm’s-length home purchases from 1990 to 2020, which records transaction prices, mortgage characteristics, and property-level identifiers. Second, Home Mortgage Disclosure Act (HMDA) records, which contain self-reported race and ethnicity for mortgage applicants. Third, supplementary administrative sources including McDash mortgage servicing records, Equifax credit bureau data, Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac/ABSNet modification records, and the Survey of Income and Program Participation (SIPP). After applying sample restrictions — including requiring an observed purchase price, a linked HMDA record, an arm’s-length repeat sale, a combined loan-to-value ratio of at most 102.5%, and an ownership spell of at least 12 months — the baseline analysis sample comprises 13.6 million ownership spells for Black, Hispanic, and White homeowners who purchased homes with a mortgage between 1990 and 2016 in 40 states. Ownership spells unsold by March 2020 have their value imputed using the FHFA county-level house price index, a procedure that is conservative in that it understates racial gaps.

Amir Kermani | Macro Paper Warehouse

Racial Disparities in Housing Returns